I promised myself I would give the UN another chance after they got a new Secretary General but what's the first thing he does? He let's a study that was conducted under the one of the most corrupt administrations in its history become a priority.
U.N. panel says global warming man-made
Fri Feb 2, 2007 9:35 AM GMT
PARIS - The U.N. climate panel issued its strongest warning (very likely as opposed to likely in ‘94) yet on Friday that human activities are heating the planet, adding pressure on governments to do more to combat accelerating global warming.
The IPCC, the most authoritative group on warming grouping 2,500 scientists from more than 130 nations, predicted more severe rains, melting glaciers, droughts, heat waves, and rising sea levels, especially if Antarctica or Greenland thaw.
“predicted more severe rains, melting glaciers, droughts, heat waves, and rising sea levels, especially if Antarctica or Greenland thaw.”
You’re kidding right? Is this really a credible scientific statement? Seems if I asked the same person “if they increased in size, would I have less rain, less drought, less heat waves and decreased sea levels” The answer isn’t as obvious as you think. If they increased, we may have less rain but we would have drought, heat waves and rising sea levels. Why you ask? Drought because the water is in the ice caps and not evaporating. Heat waves because more water is being deposited and turned into ice and not melting and rising sea because the water is being displaced by land mass. Do you think if the UN gave scientists the money to study this, they could make a good case? Or would it be called “junk” science until it had 2600 other scientists to agree. My point is 2600 scientists do not make science any more credible. “If” is not a scientific term, and a “fact” has to be irrefutable. Modeling computers on a “premise” can never be turned into a fact because a different premise would give a different conclusion. What makes one premise better than another premise? All you have is 2600 scientist agreeing to use the same premise. If I get 2600 different scientists to agree to use a different credible premise in their computer modeling, does that make it fact if they come to a different conclusion? NO, because who determines if the premise is credible? At that point you have the pro and con of Global Warming.
Lets not forget that somehow we are all supposed to forget the UN is the biggest political entity in the world and also one of the most corrupt and mismanaged. In the last 10 years, politics to the UN means one thing, more money. Are we now supposed to believe this does not have anything to do with money?
After all, there were over 10,000 lobbyist from hundreds of countries doing everything possible to get an opinion from the UN. What did the UN do? They approached 2600 scientists from around the world (from a pool of 62,000) and asked, “What are your views on Global Warming”. “If we pay for a study, will you do one on Global Warming”
Can you guess what 1800 or so scientists from countries with little or no research funds available to them said to the UN? Then the UN gave them the criteria for the study. Here is when it gets real interesting.
“Based on this data we would like to see if you come to the same conclusion”
Guess what happened? They actually came to the same conclusion. Now along with the 800 other scientists, they had already, 2600 “independent opinions” from scientists from more than 130 nations agree that “Global Warming is a real threat and man made”
Again, why doesn’t anyone look at their data or question their facts? If you haven’t gotten it yet, I’ll explain it one more time. Because there are 10,000 environmental lobbyists from nations who need to bring money into their country from the UN. When the UN says they are dedicating billions to fund research into Global Warming, nations gather up their environmental lobbyist and they are told to go get their share of the money. When the UN dedicates Billions to study AIDS, they gather up their other lobbyist to go get their share of the money.
What do you would think would happen if these nations came back with an opposing view of Global Warming? What do you think would happen if they came back with information saying their county’s AIDS cases have dropped sharply? What do you think would happen if they came and said to the UN that their poverty level has dropped sharply? Is it really in any nations best interest to oppose the UN in any way shape or form?
If a lobbyist came to me at the UN and the nation they represented came back with different data saying the Global Warming may not be man-made. Do you think I would give them money NEXT time I had a study? Or would I give it to the other 10 nations in front of me asking for the money? People can’t be so distrusting about their own government here in the US and accuse it everyday of being big brother and corrupt but somehow be altruistic and believe the UN, the biggest and most corrupt of them all.
FOUR FACTS (this is from one of many sites about the Global Warming Fraud)
Sea levels are rising. As this article explains, this claim is not the result of observable data. Like so much of the global warming industry, it is the result of frail computer modeling using dodgy or incomplete data. It is therefore not an observed value, but a wholly artificial model construct. Furthermore, the data fed into the computer is drawn from the atypical North Atlantic basin, ignoring the seas around Australia where levels have remained pretty static. And anyway, as this article explains, sea level rises have nothing to do with warmer climate. Sea levels rose during the last ice age. ( see! Increased land mass causes the sea level to rise) Warming can actually slow down sea level rise.
Ice caps are melting. Some are, some aren't. It depends on climate changes. Some are breaking up, as is normal. But some are actually expanding, as in the Antarctic where the ice sheet is growing, as this article points out. The bit of the Antarctic that is breaking up, the Larsen ice-shelf, which has been causing foaming hysteria among eco-doomsters, won't increase sea levels because it has already displaced its own weight in the sea.
The hottest years on record started in 1991. Which records? Nothing works better than pulling only the times that support your theories is there? Wonder what years were used in the modeling premise? The European climate in the Middle Ages was two degrees hotter than it is now. They grew vines in Northumberland, for heaven's sake. Then there was the Little Ice Age, which lasted until about 1880. So the 0.6% warming since then is part of a pretty normal pattern, and nothing for any normal person to get excited about.
The causal link is well established. Totally false. It is simply loudly asserted. Virtually all the scare stuff comes from computer modeling, which is simply inadequate to factor in all the -- literally-- millions of variables that make up climate change. Do you think “causal” links would change with different variables?
That's why this week's earlier eco-scare story, that more than a million species will become extinct as a result of global warming over the next 50 years, is risible. All that means is that someone has put into the computer the global warming scenario, and the computer has calculated what would happen on the basis of that premise. But -duh! -the premise is totally unproven. The real scientific evidence is that -- we just don't know; and the theories so far, linking man, carbon dioxide and climate warming. are specious. There's some seriously bad science going on in the environmentalist camp.
After Kyoto, one of the most eminent scientists involved in the National Academy of Sciences study on climate change, Richard Lindzen, professor of meteorology at MIT, blew the whistle on the politicized rubbish that was being spouted. Since his article was so significant, I reproduce it in full here:
'Last week the National Academy of Sciences released a report on climate change, prepared in response to a request from the White House, that was depicted in the press as an implicit endorsement of the Kyoto Protocol. CNN's Michelle Mitchell was typical of the coverage when she declared that the report represented "a unanimous decision that global warming is real, is getting worse, and is due to man. There is no wiggle room."
'As one of 11 scientists who prepared the report, I can state that this is simply untrue. For starters, the NAS never asks that all participants agree to all elements of a report, but rather that the report represent the span of views. This the full report did, making clear that there is no consensus, unanimous or otherwise, about long-term climate trends and what causes them.
'As usual, far too much public attention was paid to the hastily prepared summary rather than to the body of the report. The summary began with a zinger--that greenhouse gases are accumulating in Earth's atmosphere as a result of human activities, causing surface air temperatures and subsurface ocean temperatures to rise, etc., before following with the necessary qualifications. For example, the full text noted that 20 years was too short a period for estimating long-term trends, but the summary forgot to mention this.
'Our primary conclusion was that despite some knowledge and agreement, the science is by no means settled. We are quite confident (1) that global mean temperature is about 0.5 degrees Celsius higher than it was a century ago; (2) that atmospheric levels of carbon dioxide have risen over the past two centuries; and (3) that carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas whose increase is likely to warm the earth (one of many, the most important being water vapor and clouds).
'But--and I cannot stress this enough--we are not in a position to confidently attribute past climate change to carbon dioxide or to forecast what the climate will be in the future. That is to say, contrary to media impressions, agreement with the three basic statements tells us almost nothing relevant to policy discussions.
'One reason for this uncertainty is that, as the report states, the climate is always changing; change is the norm. Two centuries ago, much of the Northern Hemisphere was emerging from a little ice age. A millennium ago, during the Middle Ages, the same region was in a warm period. Thirty years ago, we were concerned with global cooling.
'Distinguishing the small recent changes in global mean temperature from the natural variability, which is unknown, is not a trivial task. All attempts so far make the assumption that existing computer climate models simulate natural variability, but I doubt that anyone really believes this assumption.
'We simply do not know what relation, if any, exists between global climate changes and water vapor, clouds, storms, hurricanes, and other factors, including regional climate changes, which are generally much larger than global changes and not correlated with them. Nor do we know how to predict changes in greenhouse gases. This is because we cannot forecast economic and technological change over the next century, and also because there are many man-made substances whose properties and levels are not well known, but which could be comparable in importance to carbon dioxide.
'What we do is know that a doubling of carbon dioxide by itself would produce only a modest temperature increase of one degree Celsius. Larger projected increases depend on "amplification" of the carbon dioxide by more important, but poorly modeled, greenhouse gases, clouds and water vapor.
'The press has frequently tied the existence of climate change to a need for Kyoto. The NAS panel did not address this question. My own view, consistent with the panel's work, is that the Kyoto Protocol would not result in a substantial reduction in global warming. Given the difficulties in significantly limiting levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide, a more effective policy might well focus on other greenhouse substances whose potential for reducing global warming in a short time may be greater.
'The panel was finally asked to evaluate the work of the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, focusing on the Summary for Policymakers, the only part ever read or quoted. The Summary for Policymakers, which is seen as endorsing Kyoto, is commonly presented as the consensus of thousands of the world's foremost climate scientists. Within the confines of professional courtesy, the NAS panel essentially concluded that the IPCC's Summary for Policymakers does not provide suitable guidance for the U.S. government.
'The full IPCC report is an admirable description of research activities in climate science, but it is not specifically directed at policy. The Summary for Policymakers is, but it is also a very different document. It represents a consensus of government representatives (many of whom are also their nations' Kyoto representatives), rather than of scientists. The resulting document has a strong tendency to disguise uncertainty, and conjures up some scary scenarios for which there is no evidence.
'Science, in the public arena, is commonly used as a source of authority with which to bludgeon political opponents and propagandize uninformed citizens. This is what has been done with both the reports of the IPCC and the NAS. It is a reprehensible practice that corrodes our ability to make rational decisions. A fairer view of the science will show that there is still a vast amount of uncertainty--far more than advocates of Kyoto would like to acknowledge--and that the NAS report has hardly ended the debate. Nor was it meant to.'
As Professor Philip Stott wrote in the Wall Street Journal on April 2 2001:
'"Global warming" was invented in 1988, when it replaced two earlier myths of an imminent plunge into another Ice Age and the threat of a nuclear winter. The new myth was seen to encapsulate a whole range of other myths and attitudes that had developed in the 1960s and 1970s, including "limits to growth," sustainability, neo-Malthusian fears of a population time bomb, pollution, anticorporate anti-Americanism, and an Al Gore-like analysis of human greed disturbing the ecological harmony and balance of the earth.
'Initially, in Europe, the new myth was embraced by both right and left. The right was concerned with breaking the power of traditional trade unions, such as the coal miners -- the labor force behind a major source of carbon-dioxide emissions -- and promoting the development of nuclear power. Britain's Hadley Center for Climate Prediction and Research was established at the personal instigation of none other than Margaret Thatcher.
'The left, by contrast, was obsessed with population growth, industrialization, the car, development and globalization. Today, the narrative of global warming has evolved into an emblematic issue for authoritarian greens, who employ a form of language that has been characterized by the physicist P.H. Borcherds as "the hysterical subjunctive." And it is this grammatical imperative that is now dominating the European media when they complain about Mr. Bush, the U.S., and their willful denial of the true faith.'
The media portrays a dramatic image of how the ice is melting in the polar regions as a consequence of global warming. We are warned that the North Pole might become icefree during the summer months at the end of this century and that the polar bears might become extinct due to this development.
But is this really a realistic image? Sure, there is research that indicates that the ice sheets are being reduced, but there are also studies that show the complete opposite. An example of this is a study in the scientific journal Geophysical Research Letter where the Swedish researcher Peter Winsor compares data collected by submarines below the Arctic ice. His conclusions are that the thickness of the ice has been almost constant between 1986 and 1997.
If you look at the South Pole there are studies that show an increase in the mass of the ice. In a study published in the journal Nature a number of polar researchers showed that they had observed a net cooling of 0.7 degrees in the region between 1986 and 2000. Another study published in Science showed that the East-Antarctic ice sheet had grown with 45 million metric tones between 1992 and 2003.
Are the ices growing or melting? The simple answer is that there exist studies that point to both directions, perhaps indicating that scientists know relatively little about global climate. But what counts to most ordinary people is what media is reporting, and media is often highlighting the most alarming studies and seldom report of studies that go against the notion that human activity leads to global warming. To put it simply, the news is filtered through an environmentalist view of the world.
An interesting example of how media sometimes gets it wrong is how journalists reported that there had never been so little ice in the Arctic than in 2005. This claim was based on satellite images by NASA which showed that the geographic extent of the ice sheet had never been so small since measurement began in 1979. One must however keep in fact that about half of the ice in the Arctic melts each summer and that two months before this measurment the extent of the ice sheet was the same as the previous year. The problem is that satellite images show the surface of the ice but not the thickness.
Capten Årnell at the summer expedition with the polar-ship Oden could tell that he had never seen so much ice in the Arctic than in 2005. It was with great difficulty that he had passed through the region. What had happened in 2005 seems to be that the ice had packed densely against the Canadian part of the Arctic. The geographical extent had been reduced but the ice was thicker.
As for polar bears, much points to that their numbers are increasing rather than diminishing. Mitch Taylor, a Canadian expert on animal populations, estimates that the number of polar bears in Canada has increased from 12 000 to 15 000 the past decade. Steven C Amstrup and his college have studied a population of polar bears in Alaska and reported that the number of females had increased from 600 to 900 between 1976 and 1992. Even a report from the WWF which is entitled "Polar bears at risk" and warns that the populations of the polar bears might become extinct due to global warming, supports that the number of polar bears is increasing. In the report the polar bears in the world are divided into 20 populations. It shows out that only 2 of these populations are decreasing, while 10 are stable, 5 are growing and 3 are not possible to comment about.
Global climate is an important issue to debate, but it is sad that what is communicated often has a clear shifting towards the worst-case scenarios and the doomsday theories. There is no reason to scare people by giving them only one side of the argument.
March 18, 2006
Nima Sanandaji [send him mail] is president of the Swedish think tank Captus and the editor of Captus Journal. He is a graduate student in biochemistry at the University of Cambridge. Fred Goldberg is associate professor at the Royal School of Technology in Stockholm and was on a Polar trip whilst writing this article.
1). Carbon dioxide is a pollutant.
2. The twentieth century has been the hottest in recorded history
and the decade 1990–2000 the hottest ever.
3. The evidence linking anthropogenic (man-made) carbon dioxide
emissions and current warming is decisive.
4. The scientific consensus is that anthropogenic CO2 emissions
have already caused significant global warming and must be
severely curtailed to prevent future climate catastrophe.
5. Anthropogenic emissions of CO2 and the global warming
caused thereby are responsible not only for higher temperatures
and more droughts than in the past, but also for more
blizzards, unseasonal snow, and freezing weather. They are
also responsible for increasing numbers of cyclones.
6. Because of anthropogenic emissions, the polar ice caps are
melting and sea levels are rising. The rising sea levels threaten
low lying island states in the Pacific and Indian Oceans with
complete inundation.
7. Unless anthropogenic emissions of CO2 are reduced by 50–
60 per cent of current levels by the year 2050, by 2100 our
descendants will have to endure global temperatures of between
1.4 to 5.8°C warmer than the present.
8. Tropical diseases such as malaria and dengue fever will spread
from the tropics to the temperate regions.
9. Shutting down coal-fired power stations and replacing them
with renewable energy sources such as windmills and solar
panels (or even nuclear power plants) will not cause unemployment
or economic deprivation.
Nine Lies About Global Warming
Ray Evans
Introduction
People who know that they are morally superior to the rest of mankind are often
tempted to ignore the moral norms on which Western civilisation depends. One of
the most important of these rules is telling the truth. The Ninth Commandment
states ‘Thou shalt not bear false witness….’ Environmentalism, however, is a form
of religious belief which fosters a sense of moral superiority in the believer, but
which places no importance on telling the truth. As the former Canadian Environment
Minister Christine Stewart put it:
No matter if the science is all phony [sic], there are collateral environmental
benefits…. Climate change [provides] the greatest chance to bring about
justice and equality in the world.1
Ever since the hot American summers of 1987 and 1988, the international environmentalist
movement has campaigned to establish a global regime of
decarbonisation. Their argument has been that increases in atmospheric concentrations
of carbon dioxide (CO2), brought about by mankind’s use of coal, oil and
gas will, through a process of greenhouse gas-induced warming, bring about global
climate catastrophe. Although this argument is inherently implausible, they have
had the most extraordinary success with their campaign. The Rio Earth Summit of
1992 led to the 1994 UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, which in
turn led, in December 1997, to the Kyoto Protocol. The essential element of the
Kyoto Protocol was that those industrialised nations which ratified the Protocol
committed themselves to specified reductions in CO2 emissions by 2012. The base
year of 1990 was chosen and each industrialised country was given a specified target
to reach. Australia’s target was 108 per cent of 1990 emissions. Only Iceland, 110
per cent, was given a more generous target. Countries which did not achieve their
targets were to be penalised in the years following 2012, and a supra-national inspectorate
was to be established to police the global decarbonisation programme.
Australia and the US, however, refused to ratify the Protocol.
Following the 11th Conference of Parties meeting in Montreal in December 2005,
the Kyoto Protocol is now almost dead. It was born in 1997 and has been sustained,
to this point, through a web of mendacity, fraud and lies. The nine most important
lies are listed on the facing page, and a brief examination of them follows.
2
1. Carbon dioxide is a pollutant
Carbon dioxide (CO2) is a colourless, odourless, tasteless, non-toxic gas which is
essential to all life on earth. (Carbon monoxide, however, is extremely toxic and, if
inhaled, will cause death very quickly.) All green vegetation requires carbon dioxide
as plant food, and the process of photosynthesis, in which plants take in carbon
dioxide, absorb solar radiation, store the carbon and emit oxygen, is basic to life. As
concentrations of carbon dioxide increase, the rates of growth of plants also increase.
Flowers and vegetables grown in hothouses are frequently fed with extra
carbon dioxide for faster growth and higher yields. As atmospheric concentrations
of carbon dioxide have increased from approximately 325 ppmv (parts per million
by volume) in 1970 to 375 ppmv today, wheat yields in Australia have increased in
the last 30 years, in part because of CO2 enrichment.
Every time a story on global warming is featured on TV, either a background image
of the cooling tower of a power station, with its plume of minute water droplets
above, or a smoke stack belching forth dark plumes of soot, fly ash, and other particulates,
is shown. In this mendacious way, carbon dioxide is identified as a serious
pollutant, and the US is always labelled as the world’s greatest polluter. (Australia is
frequently labelled as second to the US.)
Coal-fired power stations which have modern flue-gas scrubbing equipment built
into their exhaust systems, will have smoke stack emissions which are barely visible.
Mark Steyn commented:
In the past third of a century, the American economy has swollen by 150
per cent, automobile traffic has increased by 143 per cent, and energy consumption
has grown 45 per cent. During this same period, air pollutants
have declined by 29 per cent, toxic emissions by 48.5 per cent, sulphur
dioxide levels by 65.3 per cent, and airborne lead by 97.3 per cent.2
Carbon dioxide cycles naturally through the atmosphere, the earth’s land mass, and
the oceans. Huge volumes of carbon dioxide are injected into the oceans and atmosphere
during earthquakes and volcanoes. The amount of carbon contained in atmospheric
carbon dioxide is about 730,000 million tonnes (730 Gigatonnes of carbon
(GtC)). The annual transport of carbon to and from the land surface and the
atmosphere, is estimated at 120 GtC; between the oceans and the atmosphere the
estimate is 90 GtC. The annual emissions of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere
resulting from human activities is about 7 GtC, less than 1 per cent of the total
atmospheric carbon mass, and less than 4 per cent of the natural annual emissions
from the biosphere and the oceans. Changes in the natural transport of carbon, as
well as human activities, have led to recent increases in atmospheric concentrations
of carbon dioxide.
3
2. The twentieth century has been the hottest in recorded history
and the decade 1990–2000 the hottest ever.
This particular lie has done much to damage the credibility of the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change, the IPCC. The IPCC was established under the auspices
of the UNEP (United Nations Environment Panel), and the World Meteorological
Organisation (WMO). Its brief was to provide an authoritative international
statement of scientific opinion on climate change. It has issued three such
reports. The most recent, the Third Assessment Report (TAR), was released in
Shanghai in January 2001. The authority of the IPCC has been used by many governments
(including the Australian Government) as justification for various perceived
decarbonisation policies, such as the subsidies now given to the owner-operators
of wind farms, proposed carbon taxes of one kind or another, and various
carbon trading schemes which are merely add-ons to carbon taxes.
At the press conference at which this Third Assessment Report was launched, a
backdrop showing a graph of northern hemisphere temperatures from 1000 to 2000
AD was prominently displayed. This graph, known as Mann’s Hockey Stick, was so
widely used by the IPCC that it became a corporate logo. From 1000 to 1900 AD
the northern hemisphere temperature was depicted as slowly cooling by 0.2°C. From
1900 to 2000 AD the temperature took off in a straight line showing a century of
warming of 0.6°C. The graph looked like an ice hockey stick with the handle running
from 1000 to 1900 AD and the blade shooting upwards from 1900 to 2000
AD. The lead author of the research which led to this graph was Michael E. Mann
of the University of Virginia.
4
The purpose of the graph was to legitimise the claim that twentieth-century warming
is unprecedented; that it is due to anthropogenic emissions of carbon dioxide;
and that the increase in twentieth-century temperatures has been so precipitate
that drastic policies of decarbonisation have to be implemented. In particular, the
well-known history of the Mediaeval Warm Period, 800 AD to 1300 AD, an era
which was warm enough for Vikings to establish a colony in Greenland and which
lasted for 300 years, was to be airbrushed out of the historical record.3 Also deleted
from the record was the Little Ice Age which ran from 1560 to 1850 AD.
It is now established beyond argument that this hockey stick is a fraud. The algorithm
which the authors used to process tree ring data not only produced the hockey
stick published and promoted by the IPCC, but was able to produce a hockey stick
from a series of random numbers. The IPCC has not confessed to fraud. It carries on
as if nothing is wrong with its conduct or its conclusions. If the IPCC were a commercial
corporation operating in Australia, its directors would now be facing criminal
charges and the prospect of going to jail.
There is now a great deal of evidence to show that the Mediaeval Warm Period was
a global phenomenon. It was during this period that Europeans enjoyed agricultural
prosperity with an abundance of food and population growth. They made huge
progress in technology, inventing, for example, mechanical clocks and windmills,
building the great cathedrals, and establishing great trading cities such as Venice,
Amsterdam, and London. It is ironic that the global warmers should seek to erase
from the record this remarkable era of human progress as part of their campaign to
return Western society to a state of extreme energy deprivation.
As far as Australia is concerned, the highest recorded maximum temperatures for
Adelaide, Melbourne and Sydney were recorded during heatwave conditions over
south-eastern Australia that persisted from 6th to 14th January, 1939. The table
gives some maximum temperatures for this period.
Maximum Temperatures °C for days in January 1939
8th 9th 10th 11th 12th 13th 14th
Adelaide 44.0 45.9 46.1 44.2
Melbourne 43.1 44.7 45.6
Sydney 45.3
There were extensive bushfires throughout Victoria, culminating in Black Friday,
the 13th January, when 70 lives were lost. The claim that 2005 was the hottest
Australian year on record is false.4
5
3. The evidence linking anthropogenic (man-made) carbon dioxide
emissions and current warming is decisive.
If we plot global temperatures and atmospheric CO2 concentrations for the period
1970–2000, we will obtain a reasonably good correlation, and it appears plausible
to argue that anthropogenic emissions are causing global warming. A good correlation,
however, does not prove causality between the two variables, and even more
importantly, if we extend our time scale and plot fossil fuel consumption (a good
proxy for anthropogenic emissions) against temperature change, from 1860 to 2000,
we see no correlation at all.
Here we see that global temperatures rose from 1860 to 1875, then cooled until
1890, rose until 1903, fell until 1918 and then rose dramatically until 1941–42. We
then experienced the long cooling until 1976, the year of the Pacific Climate Shift,
and since then temperatures have risen by about 0.4°C. There is zero correlation
between the temperature curve and the anthropogenic CO2 curve over this 140-
year period. This fact alone should have brought the carbon dioxide-induced global
warming debate to an end.
4. The scientific consensus is that anthropogenic CO2 emissions
have already caused significant global warming and must be
severely curtailed to prevent future climate catastrophe.
Since the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change came into force in 1994,
those nations which have ratified the UNFCCC (which include Australia and the
US) send official delegates to annual meetings which are called Conferences of the
Temperature graph
Global Fossil-Fuel Use vs Temperature Change
Source: Klyashtorin and Lyubushin 2003, Energy and Environment, vol. 14, no. 6, Figure 1
6
Parties (COP). They are usually held in December, and attract an influx of about
10,000 lobbyists, activists and media personnel as well as government officials and
ministers. The NGO activists are there to generate press coverage and to stage
media events.
There is a symbiotic relationship between the NGOs, the UN bureaucrats who
comprise the Secretariat, and the delegations from the member governments, most
of whom are well paid senior officials of Departments of the Environment. For many
of these officials, global warming is not only a cause they believe in, but also the
best gravy train they can imagine.
A few days prior to COP 10, held in Buenos Aires in December 2004, the journal
Science published a paper by Dr Naomi Oreskes, a professor in history at the University
of California at San Diego. She claimed to have analysed the abstracts—using
the key words ‘climate change’—of all the scientific papers listed on the ISI database
for the decade 1993–2003. Seventy-five per cent of the 928 abstracts she
analysed (that is, 695) fell into the category, ‘either explicitly or implicitly accepting
the consensus view’. For the first time, empirical evidence was presented that
appeared to show a near unanimous scientific consensus on the anthropogenic causes
of recent global warming.
Dr Benny Peiser from John Moores University at Liverpool decided to replicate the
study. He found that a search on the ISI database using the keywords ‘climate change’
for the years 1993–2003 reveals that almost 12,000 papers were published during
the decade in question. Oreskes then admitted that she had used the keywords
‘global climate change’. This reduced the number of papers under review to 1,247,
of which 1,117 had been abstracted.
Of all 1,117 abstracts, only 13 (one per cent) explicitly endorsed the ‘consensus
view’. However, 34 abstracts rejected or questioned the view that human activities
are the main driving force of ‘the observed warming over the last 50 years’.
Oreskes claimed that ‘none of these papers argued [that current climate change is
natural]’. However, 44 papers emphasised that natural factors play a major if not the
key role in recent climate change.
Dr Peiser sent a letter to Science setting out the results of his investigation. Science
refused to publish the letter.
The Oreskes study is still quoted as evidence supporting the ‘consensus’ argument.
A statement by the Royal Society in March 2005, for instance, used Oreskes’ flawed
study as a key argument in the climate change debate.
Statistical analysis apart, a number of the most eminent scientists in the field of
physics and climate science generally have made scathing criticisms of the IPCC
and of the ‘consensus’ view. One such criticism is from Hendrik Tennekes, the world’s
7
leading authority on the physics of turbulent flow, and recently retired Director of
Research, Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute:
The climate orthodoxy perpetrates the misconceptions involved by speaking,
as IPCC does, about the Scientific Basis of Climate Change. Since
then, I have responded to that ideology by stating that there is no chance
at all that the physical sciences can produce a universally accepted scientific
basis for policy measures concerning climate change.
Australia’s Garth Paltridge, a distinguished scientist who retired recently from his
post as Director of the Antarctic CRC and IASOS at the University of Tasmania,
commented on the way in which the IPCC and its supporters operate:
Each of the successive summaries [to the IPCC’s Assessment Reports] has
been phrased in such a way as to appear a little more certain than the last
that greenhouse warming is a potential disaster for mankind. The increasing
verbal certainty does not derive from any particular advance of the
science. Rather, it is a function of how strongly a statement about global
warming can be put without inviting a significant backlash from the general
scientific community. Over the years, the opinion of that community
has been manipulated into more-or-less passive support by a deliberate campaign
to isolate—and indeed to denigrate—the scientific sceptics outside
the central activity of the IPCC. The audience has been actively conditioned
into being receptive. It has thereby become gradually easier to sell
the proposition of greenhouse disaster.
After making sceptical comments in the press about the global warming ‘consensus’,
Professor Paltridge was threatened by the CSIRO with major funding cuts to
the Antarctic Research programme for which he was responsible.
5. Anthropogenic emissions of CO2 and the global warming
caused thereby are responsible not only for higher temperatures
and more droughts than in the past, but also for more blizzards,
unseasonal snow, and freezing weather. They are also
responsible for increasing numbers of cyclones.
As the years passed and North America, the UK and Northern Europe experienced
some rather severe winters (but not as severe as the winter of 1946–47), the global
warming story began to look a bit threadbare. So the words ‘climate change’ superseded
‘global warming’, and explanations were put forward as to why increasing
anthropogenic emissions of carbon dioxide could lead to severe winters as well as
hot summers. The high point of this campaign was the movie The Day After Tomorrow
which showed New York inundated with snow and ice as global warming triggered
the onset of the next ice age.
One of the most frequent arguments in this genre is the shutting down of the Gulf
Stream by global warming with horrendous consequences for all of Europe. Carl
8
Wunsch, Professor of Physical Oceanography at MIT and the world’s leading authority
on ocean currents commented:
The only way to produce an ocean circulation without the Gulf Stream is
either to turn off the wind system, or stop the earth’s rotation, or both.
The Greenpeace protesters at the Montreal COP, held in December 2005, had to
endure blizzard conditions. Mark Steyn, writing in the London Daily Telegraph about
this event, suggested that Montreal had been relocated to
planet Goofy, a strange lost world where it’s perfectly normal for apparently
sane people to walk around protesting about global warming in subzero
temperatures. Or, as the Canadian Press reported: ‘Montreal—tens of
thousands of people ignored frigid temperatures Saturday to lead a worldwide
day of protest against global warming’.
Unfortunately, no one had supplied an updated weather forecast to the
fellow who writes the protesters’ chants. So, to the accompaniment of the
obligatory pseudo-ethnic drummers, the shivering eco-warriors sang: ‘It’s
hot in here! There’s too much carbon in the atmosphere!’ Is this the first
sign of the ‘New Ice Age’ the media warned us about last week?….
But the point is, as Steven Guilbeault of Greenpeace puts it: ‘Global warming
can mean colder, it can mean drier, it can mean wetter, that’s what
we’re dealing with.’ Got that? If it’s hot, that’s a sign of global warming,
and, if it’s cold, that’s a sign of global warming.
And if it’s just kind of average—say, 9°C, and partially cloudy, as it will be
in Llandudno today—that’s a sign that global warming is accelerating out
of control and you need to flee immediately because time is running out!
‘Time is running out to deal with climate change, says Mr Guilbeault. Ten
years ago, we thought we had a lot of time, five years ago we thought we
had a lot of time, but now science is telling us that we don’t have a lot of
time.’
In recent months Florida, Louisiana and Texas have born the brunt of some severe
cyclones. Katrina, in particular, caused enormous damage in New Orleans. Once
again the global warmers were quick to blame it all on global warming and anthropogenic
emissions. Swiss Re and Munich Re are two very large re-insurance companies
which have been doing all they can to support the argument that anthropogenic
carbon dioxide is the culprit.
There is no evidence at all to support this. There is zero correlation between the
incidence and severity of cyclones with atmospheric concentrations of CO2. Insurance
payouts, of course, have increased greatly. This is because Americans have
been migrating to the warmer south-eastern states. Florida now has a population of
20 million and the value of real estate in that State has increased accordingly.
9
6. Because of anthropogenic emissions, the polar ice caps are
melting and sea levels are rising. The rising sea levels
threaten low lying island states in the Pacific and
Indian Oceans with complete inundation.
Prior to the AP6 meeting in Sydney on 11–12 January 2006 (the Asia Pacific Partnership
on Clean Development and Climate, APPCDC), a serious public relations
exercise was conducted by representatives of the low lying Pacific Island States.
The claim made by the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) is that, because of
global warming, sea levels are rising, their islands are being submerged, and in this
particular instance the demand made of the Australian Government was that the
citizens of these states should be given permanent residency visas in Australia.
The problem here again is that there is no evidence to support their claims. The
South Pacific Sea Level and Climate Monitoring Project, funded by AusAID and
managed by the National Tidal Facility (NTF), has found no evidence of rising sea
levels.
Professor Nils Axel-Morner, head of the Paleogeophysics and Geodynamics Department
at Stockholm University, and past president of the INQUA Commission
on Sea Level Changes and Coastal Evolution, has debunked rising sea level claims.
His arguments are supported by satellite measurements which show no change in
sea level over the past decade.
Morner and his team did an exhaustive investigation of the claim made by the
IPCC that the Maldive Islands in the Indian Ocean are at risk from sea level rise
accelerated by global warming. He found considerable evidence that the sea level
in the Maldives has fallen over the past 30 years, and that the islands and their
people survived much higher sea levels in the past. What is rarely mentioned is that
many of these islands are near the boundaries of the earth’s crustal plates, whose
movement is responsible for their uplift or sinking relative to global mean sea level.
The global warmers’ argument for rising sea levels is that the polar ice caps are
melting and therefore sea levels are rising. It is revealing that many global warmers
do not understand that the Arctic Ice Cap, floating as it does in the Arctic Sea,
makes only a small difference whether it is in solid or in liquid form. The solid
form—ice—has a density 90 per cent of the liquid form, which is why it floats—
just—in water.
Whenever rising sea level stories are given a run on TV, we have shots of Antarctic
icebergs calving from the ice shelf. We do not, however, see snow falling onto the
Antarctic Ice Sheets some thousands of metres above sea level where temperatures
are rarely above freezing point. Satellite observations tell us that the Greenland Ice
Sheets are thickening, not diminishing, and that the Antarctic Ice Sheet is close to
balance.
10
7. Unless anthropogenic emissions of carbon dioxide are reduced by
50–60 per cent of current levels by the year 2050, by 2100 our
descendants will have to endure global temperatures
of between 1.4 to 5.8°C warmer than the present.
This claim is at the heart of the global warming scam. It is based on projections
coming out of models run on the most powerful computers which purport to simulate
the behaviour of the atmosphere as it responds to changes in carbon dioxide
concentrations. The claim that computer models can do this and produce meaningful
results is regarded as nonsense by leading scientists in the fields of fluid mechanics,
numerical modelling of complex systems, and climate science.
For example, Hendrik Tennekes, cited above, wrote recently:
the task of finding all nonlinear feedback mechanisms in the microstructure
of the radiation balance probably is at least as daunting as the task of
finding the proverbial needle in the haystack. The blind adherence to the
harebrained idea that climate models can generate ‘realistic’ simulations of
climate is the principal reason why I remain a climate skeptic. From my
background in turbulence I look forward with grim anticipation to the day
that climate models will run with a horizontal resolution of less than a
kilometre. The horrible predictability problems of turbulent flows then will
descend on climate science with a vengeance.
Reid Bryson, Emeritus Professor at the University of Wisconsin, and regarded by
many climatologists as the ‘father of climatology’ has written:
A model is nothing more than a formal statement about how the modeller
believes the part of the world of his concern actually works … it may be
years before computer capacity and human knowledge are adequate for
reasonable simulation … the main models in use all have similar errors,
but it is hardly surprising, for they are all essentially clones of each other.
Australia’s Bill Kininmonth, director of the National Climate Centre from 1986 to
1998, writes:
The apparent ability of the computer models to simulate the global surface
temperatures of the 20th century comes with too many assumptions and
shortcomings. Despite the IPCC advocacy, it is not possible to isolate
anthropogenic greenhouse gases as the cause (or even a major cause) for
the observed warming of the last two and a half decades of the 20th century.
The world-wide advance of mountain glaciers until the mid-19th century,
and their steady retreat since, point toward large-scale natural processes
systematically affecting the climate system over prolonged intervals.
Whether the systematic processes are internal to the climate system, an
outcome of external forcing, or a combination of these, cannot be
determined with any confidence from existing data and analysis tools. As a
corollary, the sensitivity of the earth’s temperature response to greenhouse
11
gas forcing cannot be scaled by reference to the magnitude of recent global
temperature increase and the forcing by anthropogenic greenhouse gases
as represented in computer model simulations of the 20th century.5
8. Tropical diseases such as malaria and dengue fever will spread
from the tropics to the temperate regions.
This claim is astonishing in its mendacity. As soon as the IPCC ran this argument
in 1995, it was pointed out, amongst other things, that Oliver Cromwell had died of
malaria in London in September 1658 at a particularly cold period in English history.
Paul Reiter, formerly Chief of the Entomology Section, Dengue Branch, at the
US Centre for Disease Control and Prevention in San Juan, Puerto Rico and now
at the Pasteur Institute in Paris has written extensively on malaria in England and
Northern Europe during the seventeenth century.6 His discussion of ‘the ague’ as it
is described in Shakespeare and other contemporary documents, gives a fascinating
insight into the perils of living in swampy areas such as Westminster and the coastal
marshes of the Thames estuary.
In his submission to the House of Lords Inquiry into the Economic Consequences
of Climate Change, Professor Reiter commented on the IPCC’s discussion of malaria
in its Second Assessment Report:
The scientific literature on mosquito-borne diseases is voluminous, yet the
text references in the chapter were restricted to a handful of articles, many
of them relatively obscure, and nearly all suggesting an increase in prevalence
of disease in a warmer climate. The paucity of information was hardly
surprising: not one of the lead authors had ever written a research paper
on the subject! Moreover, two of the authors, both physicians, had spent
their entire career as environmental activists. [One of these has published
‘professional’ articles as an ‘expert’ on 32 different subjects, ranging from
mercury poisoning to land mines, globalization to allergies and West Nile
virus to AIDS].
Among the contributing authors there was one entomologist, plus a person
who had written an obscure article on dengue and El Niño, but whose
principal interest was the effectiveness of motor cycle crash helmets (plus
one paper on the health effects of cell phones).
Reiter has pointed out that malaria and other ‘tropical’ diseases have more to do
with living conditions than temperature. For example he has analysed the Texas–
Mexico border, where dengue fever was prevalent in Mexico and rare in Texas despite
the similar environmental conditions. The only difference was living conditions.
Malaria is making a comeback in Africa, in central Asia, and other parts of the
world suffering from political upheaval. The IPCC’s attempt to link this to global
warming is farcical, but it is a farce with serious consequences.
12
9. Shutting down coal-fired power stations and replacing them with
renewable energy sources such as windmills and solar panels (or
even nuclear power plants) will not cause unemployment or
economic deprivation.
The Environmentalists persist in denying the economic consequences of
decarbonisation. In one particular sense they are theoretically correct. If we were
all to give up our motor cars and ride bicycles instead; if we were content to use
electricity only when the wind was blowing; if we were prepared to give up the use
of fertilizers and tractors; in effect if we were prepared to accept a standard of living
similar to that of our forebears of the early nineteenth century; we could still all be
employed, although working at night would be difficult in the absence of electricity.
In the early 1990s Aaron Wildavsky noted the implications of decarbonisation:
Global warming is the mother of environmental scares. In the scope of its
consequences for life on planet Earth and the immense size of its remedies,
global warming dwarfs all the environmental and safety scares of our time
put together. Warming (and warming alone), through its primary antidote
of withdrawing carbon from production and consumption, is capable of
realizing the environmentalist’s dream of an egalitarian society based on
rejection of economic growth in favour of a smaller population’s eating
lower on the food chain, consuming a lot less, and sharing a much lower
level of resources much more equally.7
The costs of abandoning coal-based electricity in Australia would result in the demise
of most of our export industries, namely, mining, metals processing, agriculture,
and food processing, which are highly energy intensive and thus benefit from
low-cost electricity. The numbers are important. Coal-based power in Australia
costs about $30–$40 per Megawatt hour (MWh). Nuclear power, the only practical
alternative to coal, costs $70–$80 per MWh, about twice what we now pay. Windmills,
which generate electricity when the wind is blowing, cost about $80–$130
per MWh, but require backup from reliable sources which makes them completely
uneconomic. They are currently being built on pristine coast lines and mountain
ranges because of the substantial subsidies which electricity consumers provide to
the operators of these behemoths. The burning of fuels such as bagasse, straw, sawdust,
to generate electricity is commercially attractive when the fuel is essentially a
waste product (eg bagasse), with a negative value. This happens without the need
for legislation or subsidies. Solar power costs anything between $300 and $500 per
MWh and is available when the sun is shining.
A number of economists have climbed onto the global warming bandwagon in order
to promote so-called market mechanisms to reduce carbon emissions. Emissions
trading is a popular proposal. All of these schemes are variants on the market for
taxi-cab licences. Every major city in Australia has a regime of taxi licensing in
which the number of taxis allowed to operate is limited by State regulation. This
creates a scarcity factor which increases the value of the taxi licence, and these
13
licences are traded for sums in the order of $250,000. If the regulation requiring taxi
drivers to have a licence for their taxi was abolished (as happened in New Zealand)
the value of the licence would be zero.
These licences constitute a tax which has to be paid by taxi users. Emission licences for
power stations or petrol refineries would operate in the same way. What is not known is
how great the tax on carbon emissions would have to be to ensure that electricity users
would reduce their consumption by the desired amount. In the first instance, large
electricity users such as aluminium smelters and fertilizer plants would relocate to other
countries. The Australian motor car industry, already under threat from international
competition, would close. And the ripple effect would spread out through the Australian
economy causing unemployment first in one industry and then in another.
The impact of such price increases and consequent economic dislocation would have
political consequences. No government which introduced such a regime of carbon taxation
would survive an election, but the damage that would be wrought in the meantime
would be long-lasting.
Conclusion
The global warming scam has been, arguably, the most extraordinary scientific event
in the post-War period. So many people, and institutions, have been caught up in
the web of deceit, master-minded by environmental activists working through the
NGOs and their manipulation of the IPCC processes, that the integrity of Western
science is seriously at risk. The unravelling of this web will result in the loss of
reputation for many individuals, but more importantly, in the restructuring of those
scientific institutions in Australia and elsewhere which have tied their reputations
to that of the IPCC. That issue is now moving onto the political agenda.
Endnotes
1. Calgary Herald, 14 December 1998.
2. London Daily Telegraph, 6 December 2005.
3. In his book Civilisation, based on the incomparable TV series, Kenneth Clark wrote,
‘There have been times in the history of man when the earth seems suddenly to have
grown warmer or more radioactive…. [one such time] was about the year 1100 that
seemed to affect the whole world but had its most dramatic effect in Western Europe
… The cathedrals of Durham and Canterbury arose out of clusters of wooden houses
… in a single lifetime.
4. See Warwick Hughes’ analysis at: http://www.warwickhughes.com/cool/cool15.htm
5. Bill Kininmonth, Climate Change: A Natural Hazard, Multi-Science Publishing Co.
Ltd, UK, pages 192–3.
6. For example, ‘From Shakespeare to Defoe: Malaria in England in the Little Ice Age’,
available at: http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/eid/vol6no1/reiter.htm
7. ‘Introduction’ to Robert Balling Jr, The Heated Debate, PRIPP, San Francisco, 1992.
The Lavoisier Group is named after the founder of modern chemistry, Antoine-
Laurent Lavoisier, who discovered oxygen, identified carbon dioxide as the product
of combustion of carbon in air, and who laid down the theoretical basis of
modern chemistry. He was also an ingenious experimenter and instrument-maker
who insisted on the highest possible accuracy when taking measurements. He
was executed by the French Revolutionary Government in 1794.
The Lavoisier Group was incorporated in April 2000. At that time, the founders
were concerned that the Australian Government might ratify the Kyoto Protocol
without proper understanding of the scientific claims on which it was based, or
of the economic implications of the decarbonisation regime which ratification
would have required.
In June 2002, Prime Minister John Howard stated in the Parliament that Australia
would not ratify Kyoto because it was ‘not in Australia’s interests to do so’. The
ALP has consistently adhered to a policy of ratification, but having lost the
2004 election, the possibility of Australia’s ratification has been deferred until
2007.
Meanwhile the debate has moved on. The Kyoto Protocol is now almost dead;
only two of its parties can possibly meet the 2012 emissions targets which were
accepted in 1997, and no country is prepared to commit to post-2012 emission
targets. Following a change in government, Canada may now formally withdraw
from the Kyoto Protocol, thus setting an example to be followed by other nations.
Nevertheless, there still exists a huge global network of institutions and scientists
who have hitched their wagons to the global warming star. Although the science
debate is now virtually over, the political debate will continue for years to come.
The Lavoisier Group provides a network and a Website which enables Australians
who are concerned about this issue to keep abreast of developments here and
overseas. Those who sympathise with our aims, and wish to join, can apply for
membership through the Website: www.lavoisier.com.au
The Lavoisier Group’s Board comprises President The Hon. Peter Walsh AO;
Vice-President Ian Webber AO; Treasurer Harold Clough AO; Bruce Kean AM;
Bob Foster; Tom Bostock; George Fox AM; and Secretary Ray Evans.
GLOBAL WARMING SCAM...
How interesting!
Consider the simple fact, drawn from the official temperature records of the Climate Research Unit at the University of East Anglia, that for the years 1998-2005 global average temperature did not increase (there was actually a slight decrease, though not at a rate that differs significantly from zero). And also, yes, this eight-year period of temperature stasis did coincide with society's continued power station and SUV-inspired pumping of yet more carbon dioxide into the atmosphere.
Hang on a second, there must be some mistake, right? Wrong.
There was a period of global warming between 1970 and 1998. And there was another similar period of warming between 1918 and 1940. Then, global temperatures COOLED until 1964, just as human emissions were surging all over the planet! Shurely shome mistake???
Here's the point; Climate changes naturally all the time, partly in predictable cycles, and partly in unpredictable shorter rhythms and rapid episodic shifts, some of the causes of which remain unknown. The "end of the world is coming" cacophony emitted by the likes of the UK's Chief Scientific Adviser, Sir David King, is just plain nonsense, lapped up by headline hungry liberal MSM.
That industrial carbon dioxide is not the primary cause of earth's recent decadal-scale temperature changes doesn't seem at all odd to many thousands of independent scientists. But the prophets of global warming have their eyes wide closed......and that's a fact!
Tim Blair has an interesting take on the issue here.
Since 1970, carbon monoxide emissions in the U.S. are down 55%, according to the Environmental Protection Agency. Particulate emissions are down nearly 80% and sulfur dioxide emissions have been reduced by half. Lead emissions have declined more than 98%.
And yet...
Polar bears are drowning; an American city is underwater; ice sheets are crumbling ... the rate of warming from the 1970’s until now has been three times the average rate of warming since 1900. Seas have risen about six to eight inches globally over the last century and the rate of rise has increased in the last decade
So, Tim suggests that we blame this on decreased carbon monoxide, particulate, sulfur dioxide, and lead emissions. For the sake of all the drowning polar bears, let’s get those pollutants up! Yeah, time to go out in my 4x4!
The scam of global warming is that we pay others for our complacency
The most destructive effect of the carbon offset trade is that it allows us to believe we can carry on polluting George MonbiotTuesday January 17, 2006The Guardian
Sometimes I envy the self-belief of the Daily Mail's columnist Melanie Phillips. When Andrew Wakefield, a researcher at the Royal Free Hospital, suggested that there might be a link between autism and the MMR injection, she decided he was right. Despite the failure of further studies to find any evidence, despite the fact that Wakefield's co-researchers have dissociated themselves from his allegation, and though the medical profession, almost without exception, is persuaded that his claim has no merit, she persists. The epidemiologists are guilty of "category confusion"; the scientific reviewers are throwing up "clouds of obfuscation"; her critics are peddlers of "ignorance, misrepresentation and smear".
She's just as sure of her position on climate change. Last year she told listeners to the Moral Maze that manmade climate change "is a massive scam based on flawed computer modelling, bad science and an anti-western ideology ... a pack of lies and propaganda". Soon afterwards, the Royal Society published a "guide to facts and fictions about climate change", whose purpose was to address the arguments made by people like her. It destroyed all the claims she had been making. A few months later, the deniers' last argument fell away, as three studies showed that satellite data suggesting the atmosphere had cooled were faulty. New Scientist reported that "as nails in the coffin go, they don't get much bigger".
But nothing can stop her. Last week she resumed the attack. Manmade climate change is "one of the greatest scientific scams of the modern age", an artefact of "ideology, irrationality and pseudoscientific sloppiness". "The rate of warming over the past century," she claimed, "is nothing out of the historical ordinary." We also learnt that "most of [the atmosphere] consists of water vapour": the climatologists must have been lying about that too.
As usual, the scientists have the science wrong, and only Phillips, autodidact professor of epidemiology, gastroenterology, meteorology and atmospheric physics, can put them right. Where does she get it from? How do you acquire such confidence in your own rectitude that neither the evidence itself, nor the Royal Society, nor the combined weight of the major scientific journals can alter by a whisker the line you have taken? Are you born knowing you have prophetic powers: that everything you believe is and will forever be true? Or does it come with experience? If so, what might that experience be?
The occasion for her latest outburst was a study published last week in Nature, which showed, to everyone's astonishment, that plants produce methane, a greenhouse gas. Phillips used the findings to suggest that the entire science of global warming had been disproved and that there was no need to worry about the biosphere. Nature came to the opposite conclusion: as methane emissions from plants rise with temperature, climate change will cause further climate change.
But while this study does nothing to threaten global warming theory, there is something it challenges. It should shake our confidence in one of our favourite means of tackling it: paying other people to clear up the mess we've made.
Both through the unofficial carbon market and by means of a provision of the Kyoto protocol called the "clean development mechanism", people, companies and states can claim to reduce their emissions by investing in carbon friendly projects in poorer countries. Among other schemes, you can earn carbon credits by paying people to plant trees. As the trees grow, they are supposed to absorb the carbon we release when we burn fossil fuels.
Despite the new findings, it still seems fair to say that forests are a net carbon sink, taking in more greenhouse gases than they release. If they are felled, the carbon in the trees and the soil they grow on is likely to enter the atmosphere. So preserving them remains a good idea, for this and other reasons. But what the new study provides is yet more evidence that the accountancy behind many of the "carbon offset" schemes is flawed.
While they have a pretty good idea of how much carbon our factories and planes and cars are releasing, scientists are much less certain about the amount of carbon tree-planting will absorb. When you drain or clear the soil to plant trees, for example, you are likely to release some carbon, but it is hard to tell how much. Planting trees in one place might stunt trees elsewhere, as they could dry up a river that was feeding a forest downstream. Or by protecting your forest against loggers, you might be driving them into another forest. As global temperatures rise, trees in many places will begin to die back, releasing the carbon they contain. Forest fires could wipe them out completely. The timing is also critical: emissions saved today are far more valuable, in terms of reducing climate change, than emissions saved in 10 years' time, yet the trees you plant start absorbing carbon long after your factories released it. All this made the figures speculative, but the new findings, with their massive uncertainty range (plants, the researchers say, produce somewhere between 10% and 30% of the planet's methane) make an honest sum impossible.
In other words, you cannot reasonably claim to have swapped the carbon stored in oil or coal for carbon absorbed by trees. Mineral carbon, while it remains in the ground, is stable and quantifiable. Biological carbon is labile and uncertain.
To add to the confusion, to show that you are really reducing atmospheric carbon by planting or protecting a forest, you must demonstrate that if you hadn't done it something else would have happened. Not only is this very difficult to do, it is also an invitation for a country or a company to threaten an increase in emissions. It can then present the alternative (doing what it would have done anyway) as an improvement on its destructive plans, and claim the difference as a carbon reduction.
There's a good example in Brazil. A company in the state of Minas Gerais runs a big eucalyptus plantation, which it uses to produce charcoal for smelting pig iron. Many of the locals hate it, because it grabbed their land and has replaced the diverse forest and savannah that sustained them with a monoculture. Now it claims that it should be paid by rich nations to maintain its plantations because otherwise the companies it supplies would switch to coal. The locals allege that the company had no intention of abandoning its trees until it saw the potential of the carbon market. They also say it will be rewarded for keeping the rightful owners off their land.
But perhaps the most destructive effect of the carbon offset trade is that it allows us to believe we can carry on polluting. The government can keep building roads and airports and we can keep flying to Thailand for our holidays, as long as we purchase absolution by giving a few quid to a tree-planting company. How do you quantify complacency? How do you know that the behaviour the trade induces does not cancel out the carbon it sequesters?
In other words I think it is fair to say that a scam is being perpetrated, but not of the kind Melanie Phillips alleges. We know that climate change will impoverish many people. We now know that it will make others very rich - but their money-making schemes will have precious little to do with saving the planet.http://www.monbiot.com/
The Global Warming Hoax
By Alan CarubaNational Anxiety Center June 23, 2005
On June 13, USA Today declared, "The Debate's Over: Globe Is Warming." That's another headline you can ignore. The world has been warming ever since the last Ice Age, but it is not rapidly warming in ways that threaten our existence, nor warming in a way that requires the industrialized nations to drastically cut back on their use of energy to avoid the many scenarios of catastrophe the Greens have been peddling since the 1980s.Global warming is a classic scare campaign initiated by the Greens after a previous effort in the 1970s to influence public policy by declaring a coming Ice Age failed to generate any response. What we are seeing now is yet another worldwide coordinated campaign by the Greens to rescue the global warming theory from the junk heap to which it should be consigned.In early June, the National Resources Defense Council, one of the large Green organizations, declared that, "Global warming is fast becoming the number one environmental problem of our time." It has organized an Internet campaign led by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., Sen. John McCain, and other so-called environmental leaders to drum up the fears of people who know little of the real science of the Earth in order to force the US to implement the United Nations Kyoto protocol on "climate control." Anyone who thinks humans have any control over the Earth's climate is willfully ignoring the evidence that we have none.The NRDC declared, "The world's leading scientists now agree that global warming is real and is happening right now. According to their forecasts, extreme changes in climate could produce a future in which erratic and chaotic weather, melting ice caps and rising sea levels usher in an era of drought, crop failure, famine, flood and mass extinctions." Scary, eh? One huge volcanic eruption could do this. As to the weather, it is the very definition of chaos and has been for billions of years.The good news is that leading climatologists and meteorologists are actively debunking this nonsense. One of them, Dr. F. Fred Singer, president of the Science and Environmental Policy Project, is in the forefront. He debunks a June 7 statement issued by several national academies of sciences just before Britain's Tony Blair arrived for talks with President Bush, saying, "The Statement simply regurgitates the contentious conclusions of the (UN) International Panel on Climate Change report of 2001, which has been disputed by credible scientists. The so-called scientific consensus is pure fiction."Among the data he cites is the fact that, "Since 1940, there has been a 35-year-long cooling trend and not much warming in the past quarter-century, according to global data from weather satellites." Moreover, "an extrapolation of the satellite data gives at most a fraction of a degree rise for the 2lst century," adding that, "The IPCC further claims that the 20th century was the warmest in the past 100 years, but this myth is based on a seriously flawed publication. The IPCC also claims that sea levels will rise by up to nearly a meter by 2100; but every indication is that they will continue to rise inexorably and much less, as they have for nearly 20,000 years since the peak of the last Ice Age."Bear in mind that the IPCC is a creation of the United Nations and we have all seen how corrupt that institution has become, failing to fulfill its mandate for a more peaceful world while seeking to become a world government that would destroy the sovereignty of the United States and all other nations.Other scientists have joined Dr. Singer to dispute the global warming claims. Paul Knappenberger of the University of Virginia, says of the claims made by the science academies that, "What is missing is the scientific assessment of the potential threat. Without a threat assessment, a simple scientific finding on its own doesn't warrant any change of action, no matter how scientifically groundbreaking it might be." What passes for a threat assessment is simply the claim being made. Knappenberger noted, "The fact of the matter is that there does exist a growing body of scientific evidence that the climate changes in the coming decades will be modest and proceed at a rate that will lie somewhere near the low end of the IPCC projected temperature range."Here's what you must keep in mind; the IPCC claims are based on what virtually every scientist knows to be seriously flawed computer models for its projections. In short, we are being asked to believe what computer engineers are telling us, not what credible climatologists and meteorologists are telling us. There isn't a computer model for the world's weather that can reliably predict the future by more than a week at best. This is why tracking the routes of hurricanes proves so difficult. This is why blizzards often turn out to be better or worse than initial projections.Iain Murray, another scientist, laid into the statement of the national academies for having committed the sin of advocacy. "Climate alarmists in the scientific community now face a long retreat, while the victory of President Bush's position on the issue seems assured. Even the hopes of European intervention are dashed." The U.S. Senate unanimously rejected signing the Kyoto protocol many years ago. "Rational nations will not take action if the costs of the action outweigh the benefits," said Murray of the protocol's demand for energy caps on emissions while exempting nations like China and India, each with more than a billion people.Meanwhile, in Congress we have people like Sen. Jeff Bingaman, D-NM, the ranking member of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, seeking to introduce legislation that would put "caps" on emissions of greenhouse gases and implementing what is essentially the Kyoto protocol that the Senate rejected long ago. The Department of Energy has estimated that a cap-and-trade program such as Bingaman proposes would cost $331 billion in lost GDP between 2010 and 2025. Other Senators like McCain and Lieberman have similar strategies. In my view, caps are idiotic.
There is no scientific consensus. There is only the manipulation of public opinion and the effort to influence public policy. There is no rapid global warming and no way that any limits on energy use could have any effect on it if it did exist. Global warming is a classic scare campaign and we may well be witnessing its last desperate gasps as more and more scientists step forward to debunk it.
